Jump to content

Dev talks of PC gamers "consolization" fears

Pave Low

Recommended Posts

Posted on the EA forums:

Early on BFBC2 our PC playtest feedback showed that weapon feeling was lacking. It just wasn't as much fun to shoot the guns on PC as on console. With controls being the big gameplay difference (mouse vs pad) it quickly became clear that simply put the original weapon tweaks, which were done on the PS3, weren't working on PC. The guns all had a bit of base inaccuracy, that with a gamepad wasn't really noteworthy, but on PC it really prevented players from taking advantage of the mouse input. On 2142 one of the key things about the guns is that they were all deadly accurate, they lost damage over range sure, but if you could put the crosshairs on the target you could hit it. Sure, some people feel like an AR should be more accurate than an SMG or carbine. I feel like the issue is "ARs should be better at range" and thus, they do better damage over range than the SMGs.

In response to the feedback on PC, I completely retweaked the accuracy. The next playtest it was immediately obvious that it was a change for the better, and surprisingly it also made gamepads feel much better as well.

Fundamentally I think it is an error to have different core gameplay on console vs PCs. PC gives a player more input control and if a gun feels good on PC it feels good on console. I won't "dumb it down" by lowering the recoil or changing the damage model or other such silliness.

PC and Console Battlefield players want similar gameplay: Epic sprawling Battlefields, and also tight infantry fights. Balanced weapons and land/sea/air vehicles with a rock-paper-scissors emphasis. Squad and teamplay, where no one player can be a do-it-all super soldier, and communications systems to support teamplay. And a deep and rewarding system of progression with deep and varied gameplay that keeps you wanting to go 1 more round. Everyone also wants it to be easy to play with their friends.

Consoles generally are less tolerant of overly complex interfaces. They have less buttons, you need more elegant interfaces. Deep systems work well though if they have a straight forward interface. The fun is not in figuring out how to use the system, it's in figuring out how to best use the system.

PC players have their own set of requirements. They tend to play only on PC, and they know their PCs have capabilities beyond that of a console. The gap is narrowing, but PCs still have a clear advantage in memory. PC players also demand a PC interface, a server browser, and anything that feels like it might have been "ported" from a console is going to get flamed hard. They are more forgiving of complex systems and will tear any design down into its parts to really figure out how it works. It's a damn sight harder to please a PC player, they have higher expectations.

It's too early to talk BF3 specifics. But it's never too early for me to acknowledge that PC players have a fear that BF3 will be "consolized." PC gaming is alive and well, BFBC2 has proven that and no one at DICE or EA can argue with the numbers. Battlefield 3 needs an extra bit of special attention on the PC. I intend to give it that attention, tradition and our community demand it.



Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love that guy! BF3 was already on my list, after reading that, it's a definite purchase, probably. :whistle:

Along similar lines, did anyone catch the xplay interview with the Gears of War 3 developer? The quote that made me sit up being...

"Why fight the community,... lets embrace it and give them what they want"

When I heard that it almost made me want to buy that game. Dedicated servers too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think they have no choice to make it PC before console cause if they want to make it at 64 players multiplayer,console won't support more than 32....and like you R0CKY I will buy this game for sure but the difference is that I was sold out the day the rumours came out ;)...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

a tweet by DICE Dev David Goldfarb confirms that while it wont be a PC exclusive, the PC version will be special

Can you PLEASE put the rumors to rest that #BF3 will be a PC exclusive?

it will not be exclusive.

We are putting special effort into the pc version, even for us, it's extraordinary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I swear IW and Ubi have scarred me for life. Every time I see a dev or publisher say something like that I immediately think they are lying and theyre just saying that to hype the gamers. I really wish I could believe anything anyone in the game industry says. Regardless I am looking forward to BF3 and the new game from Respawn.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...